Behind the scenes: how we actually review a game
People sometimes ask whether we just skim games and slap a number on them. Fair question, given how many sites do exactly that. Here's our actual process.
First, someone claims a game and commits to real playtime — usually several evenings. We take notes as we go, because first impressions and day-five impressions are often very different.
Then we talk. Every review gets a second pair of eyes, and if two of us disagree sharply we both play more until we understand why. The final score reflects that discussion.
We also try to review for the right audience. A hardcore strategy game shouldn't be judged by casual standards, and vice versa. The goal is helping the right player decide.
It's slower than cranking out ten reviews a week, but it's the only way we'd feel honest about the scores we give.
